You may be a spouse dividing a house, an executor listing what an estate owns, a trustee preparing to distribute a home, or an owner in San Diego County who wants a number before deciding anything else. In each of these situations someone is going to ask what the property is worth, and a guess or an online figure may not hold up when the stakes are real. This page sets out what a private home appraisal involves, when it tends to come up, and how it compares with the other ways of putting a value on a home.

An independent home appraisal is a written opinion of a home's value that the owner orders directly from an appraiser, outside any lender's process. Because the owner orders it, the report is prepared for the owner's own purpose, such as a divorce, an estate, a trust, a planned sale or a property tax question.
On this page
Key Takeaways
- What it is. An independent home appraisal, also called a private home appraisal, is an appraisal the owner orders directly, outside a lender's process. An appraiser inspects the home, studies comparable sales and writes an opinion of value as of a stated date.
- How it differs from a lender's appraisal. A lender-ordered appraisal is ordered by the bank or loan company as part of a loan decision, and the lender controls it, though on a loan to be secured by a first lien on a dwelling the lender must give the applicant "a copy of all appraisals and other written valuations." An independent appraisal is ordered by and prepared for the owner.
- How it differs from a CMA. A comparative market analysis (CMA) is a real estate agent's review of recent comparable sales, usually prepared to suggest a listing price. It is not an appraisal.
- How it differs from an AVM. An automated valuation model (AVM) is a computer-generated estimate built from public records and sales data, with no one inspecting the property. It is not an appraisal either.
- Where requests go. San Diego Home Appraisal & Valuation is not an appraiser and does not appraise property, set a property's value, or give legal or tax advice; a reader can request an appraisal quote through its form.
When This Option Fits
The situations below are the ones in which an owner-ordered appraisal usually comes up. Each is described on its own terms; which one matches a given property depends on its facts.
Divorce or legal separation. For dividing the community estate, California law provides that "the court shall value the assets and liabilities as near as practicable to the time of trial" (Family Code section 2552). The same section allows an exception: on 30 days' notice by the moving party to the other party, the court for good cause shown may value all or part of the assets and liabilities at a date after separation and before trial. For a spouse, this means the value that matters is tied to a date the court uses, and an independent appraisal can be prepared as of that date.
Estate and probate. Under Probate Code section 8900, "the appraisal of property in the inventory shall be made by the personal representative, probate referee, or independent expert as provided in this chapter." Separately, Evidence Code section 813 provides that, in the proceedings its valuation provisions govern (such as eminent domain), the value of property may be shown only by the opinions of qualified witnesses, the owner or the owner's spouse, or a knowledgeable designated officer, regular employee, or partner of an owning entity; it is not a general probate valuation rule. The broader steps of estate and probate appraisals sit alongside this rule.
Trust administration. A trustee distributing or transferring a home often wants a written value for the beneficiaries and the records.
Before listing. An owner may want an appraiser's opinion before choosing an asking price.
A property tax question. The county assessor's assessed value, set under Proposition 13 rules, can differ from current market value, and an owner may want a market value to compare.
Refinance planning. Lenders often, though not always, need an appraisal. A federal rule at 12 C.F.R. § 34.43 requires one for real estate-related financial transactions "except those in which" any of its listed conditions applies.
Who Values Property in a Probate Inventory
In plain terms, Probate Code section 8900 names who may appraise the property listed in an estate inventory: the personal representative, the probate referee, or an independent expert as provided in that chapter. The chapter divides that work rather than making these appraisers interchangeable: the personal representative generally appraises cash and cash-equivalent items, while other property is generally left to the probate referee or, where the chapter provides, an independent appraiser. An independent appraisal ordered by the estate does not replace that rule; it is one more written value the personal representative and the estate's attorney can weigh, and it may matter more when the estate is contested or the property is hard to value.
How It Works, Step by Step
A private appraisal follows a predictable sequence, and seeing it laid out makes each stage easier to plan around.
- Quote request. The owner describes the property and the reason for the appraisal through a request form.
- Independence. The appraiser works independently of any lender.
- Inspection. The appraiser schedules a visit and inspects the property, noting its size, layout, condition and features.
- Written report. The appraiser researches comparable sales and prepares a written appraisal report stating an opinion of value as of a specific date.
- The owner uses the report. The owner takes the report to the purpose that prompted it: a divorce proceeding, an estate inventory, a trust distribution, a listing decision or a tax question.
One feature sets this route apart. Because the appraisal is prepared for the owner, not for a lender, the owner decides who sees it: a spouse's attorney, a personal representative, a trustee, a real estate agent or no one at all.
Types of Appraisal Reports
Appraisals differ in how the appraiser gathers information about the property. The common forms are:
- Full inspection. The appraiser visits and inspects the interior and exterior of the home, as in the steps above.
- Drive-by (exterior-only). The appraiser views the home from the outside and relies on records and other sources for interior details.
- Desktop. The appraiser does not visit the property and works from records, data and information supplied by others.
Which form suits a given assignment depends on the purpose of the report and on who will rely on it; the appraiser discusses this when the request is made.
Purpose and the Date of Value
Two details shape every independent appraisal report: why it is being prepared and the date the value is stated as of. A listing decision usually looks at value today. A divorce looks to the date the court will use under Family Code section 2552. An estate inventory often looks back to the date of death. Because the purpose drives both the kind of report and its effective date, an appraiser asks about the purpose at the start, and two reports on the same home can state different values simply because they answer different questions.
Costs, Timing and Trade-offs
Price and turnaround vary from one property to the next, and the factors behind them are easier to describe than any single figure.
What shapes the cost. The main factors are the home's size, how complex it is to value (an unusual design, a large lot or few comparable sales), where it sits within San Diego County, and the intended use of the report. An appraisal for an estate or a divorce may need a past or specific effective date and more explanation than one ordered for a listing decision.
What shapes the timing. Timing depends on the appraiser's schedule, how easily the property can be reached and entered (an occupied home, a tenant, a locked estate property), and how much research the report needs.
The trade-off. An independent appraisal costs money and takes time. In exchange, the owner gets a written value opinion, prepared for the owner's own purpose by an appraiser who inspected the home, that can be explained and defended if questioned. Where the value goes into a divorce, a probate inventory or an estate, a formal written appraisal generally carries more weight than an agent's CMA or an automated estimate, which the table below compares.
Options to Compare
Each way of putting a number on a home was built for a different job. The table sets them side by side.
| Option | Who prepares it | What it is good for | Its limits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Independent (owner-ordered) appraisal | An appraiser the owner engages | A formal written value for a divorce, estate, trust, sale or tax question; the owner controls the report | Costs money and takes time |
| Lender-ordered appraisal | An appraiser engaged for the lender | The lender's loan decision | Ordered for the lender, which typically controls how it is used and shared |
| Comparative market analysis (CMA) | A real estate agent | Setting or testing a listing price; often offered at no charge as part of earning a listing | Not a formal appraisal |
| Automated valuation model (AVM) | A computer algorithm | A quick, immediate starting point | No inspection and no appraiser; can miss condition and features |
| Assessed value | The San Diego County Assessor | Calculating property tax | Set under Proposition 13 rules; may differ significantly from current market value |
None of these is the answer for every situation. A seller testing the market may find a CMA enough, while an executor filing an inventory faces a different question. For a quick look at a single address, a home value review by address is a market estimate, not an appraisal. The broader question of what a home is worth covers how these figures relate to each other.
What to Have Ready
A request moves more smoothly when the basic facts are gathered first. Gathering them also makes the quote more accurate, because the quote depends on the property and the purpose.
- Property address and assessor's parcel number (APN). The APN is the number the county uses to identify the parcel. It appears on San Diego County Assessor records.
- A recent property tax bill or assessment notice. It confirms the APN and shows the current assessed value.
- Any prior appraisal reports. Earlier reports help an appraiser understand the property's history.
- Notes on improvements and permitted work. A remodel, an added room or a new roof, along with any permit records, affects how the home compares with others.
- The purpose of the appraisal. The appraiser needs it to choose the right kind of report and the date the value is stated as of.
- For an estate or probate matter: the date of death. The personal representative or the estate's attorney can confirm which date the value should be stated as of.
- For a divorce: the date the court will use under Family Code section 2552, described above. The spouse's attorney can say which date applies.
A residential appraisal draws on these same basics whatever its purpose.
Local Context: San Diego County
San Diego County holds a wide range of properties: bluff-top and coastal homes in La Jolla, Carlsbad, Encinitas and Oceanside; older neighborhoods and newer subdivisions in Chula Vista and National City; inland and hillside lots around Escondido, Poway, El Cajon and Santee. That range matters because an appraiser looks for comparable sales that truly resemble the subject home, and a home near the coast, on a steep hillside or on an unusual lot may have fewer close matches than a typical suburban house.
The San Diego County Assessor's office administers property tax assessments under Proposition 13. An assessed value and an independent appraisal serve different purposes and are set by different processes, so the two figures may differ.
Appraisers in California are credentialed by a state agency, the California Bureau of Real Estate Appraisers (BREA). An owner engaging an appraiser can check that person's status with BREA.
The assessor's record for the property, showing its current APN and assessed value, is a useful first document to find before a quote request, since it anchors both the request and any later comparison.
Take the next step
Ready to take the next step with your property?
Tell us about the property and why you need an appraisal, so an independent appraiser can confirm the right scope of work.
How it works
- The propertyIts address and its type.
- The purposeA sale, an estate or probate, a divorce, a trust, tax or a legal matter.
- Your timelineWhen the appraisal is needed.
Take the next step
How we work
- Every request is reviewed by a person. Nothing on this site calculates a value automatically.
- Appraisals are prepared by independent, state-licensed or certified appraisers, never by this website.
- Estimates and cash offers are clearly labeled — never presented as appraisals.
- A request does not commit you to anything.
Frequently asked questions
What does an appraiser do?
An appraiser forms a written opinion of a property's value as of a specific date. The work includes inspecting the home, researching recent sales of comparable properties, adjusting for differences between them and the subject home, and setting out the conclusion and its reasoning in a written report.
How much does it cost to get a property appraised?
No statutory filing fee is involved in a private appraisal; the price is set by the appraiser. It varies with the home's size and complexity, its location within San Diego County and the report's intended use. A quote request describing the property and its purpose is how an owner gets a figure tied to the facts.
What is the difference between an independent appraisal and a home value estimate?
The difference lies in who stands behind the number and for what use. An appraisal carries an appraiser's signed opinion and reasoning, which can be examined if the value is questioned. An estimate, such as those compared in the table above, is a starting point that is not prepared for legal or lending purposes.
Can a home be bought or sold without an appraisal?
It depends largely on financing. For the institutions it covers, 12 C.F.R. § 34.43 generally requires an appraisal for real estate-related financial transactions, except where one of its listed conditions applies. A sale with no loan falls outside that lending rule, though the buyer, the seller or their contract may still call for one.
What should I not tell an appraiser?
An appraiser forms an independent opinion, so the useful role for an owner is sharing facts: improvements, permitted work, repairs, and dates that matter to the purpose. Suggesting a target number or pressing for a particular conclusion works against that independence. A report that reflects the appraiser's own judgment is the one that holds up when questioned.
How does an independent appraisal differ from the San Diego County Assessor's assessed value?
They answer different questions. The assessor sets an assessed value for property tax under Proposition 13 rules, and it may differ significantly from current market value. An independent appraisal states market value as of a specific date for the owner's own purpose.
When is an independent appraisal required for a divorce in California?
Family Code section 2552 tells the court when to value property, not who must appraise it; that timing rule is set out above. An independent appraisal stated as of the date the court will use gives a spouse a value to present. An attorney can say how the rule applies to a particular case.
Is an independent appraisal needed for probate in California?
Not always. Under Probate Code section 8900, the personal representative, the probate referee or another appraiser the chapter allows makes the inventory appraisal, and Evidence Code section 813 lets an owner give an opinion of value. A contested or complex estate may lead the parties to order a formal independent appraisal.