Options and Trade-offs
Each path below has a cost and a benefit. None is the answer for every property, and the choice depends on the owner's timing, finances and what the records show about the unit.
Selling with a permitted ADU. The unit is disclosed, the appraiser can credit it, and comparable ADU sales in the area support its value. The trade-off is mostly about pricing: a value set without good comparables can still be questioned by a buyer or a lender.
Selling with an unpermitted ADU. The property can be sold in its present condition, with the unit's status disclosed. The unit may be credited at less than full value or not at all, and a buyer may ask for permits as a condition of the sale or negotiate the price down.
Permitting before a sale. Bringing the unit through the permit process takes time and money, and the work the building department requires is not known in advance. In return, a permitted unit may be credited in the appraisal and leaves a buyer less room to negotiate over its status.
Using ADU rent in a refinance. Lenders may count documented rental income from a permitted ADU toward the owner's qualifying income, under the guidelines the loan follows. An appraisal is part of that process, and a lender or loan officer can say what documentation it accepts.
Getting an appraisal first. An owner who wants to understand the ADU's contribution before choosing among these paths can request an appraisal quote through San Diego Home Appraisal & Valuation. An owner more focused on overall equity may look at a home equity value review as a starting point.
Comparing written figures, such as estimated net proceeds after commissions, permit and repair costs, loan payoffs and closing costs, is how an owner tells which path fits the property.